Case Study

The Renovate or Rebuild TV Show

Using Behavioural Science to Drive Change in the Housing Sector

What we did and why

Our homes already produce around 13 per cent of Australia’s greenhouse gas emissions. If our population continues to grow at its current rate, to an estimated 41 million people by 2050, we will need to construct as many as 197,000 homes a year. This is in addition to the estimated $36BN of home renovations that occur in Australia each year. Whether these homes make our cities and communities safe, resilient and sustainable or contribute to combating climate change and its impacts by leading the transition towards a lower carbon, 100% renewable future is up to us.

We worked with the New South Wales Government, CSIRO, the Co-operative Research Centre for Low Carbon Living, and range of industry partners like GBCA, ASBEC, HIA, MBA, and ReNew to develop a behaviour change program with the objective of getting consumers to build more sustainable housing.

In a world first, this project developed a science based communications strategy involving the creation of a Lifestyle TV show that integrated the latest research in behavioural science to accelerate the uptake of net zero energy/carbon homes and associated technology (eg electric vehicles) in Australia’s residential housing sector.

Outcomes

In this project we achieved the following:

  • 8 x 1 hour episodes of a new Lifestyle TV Show that premiered on channel 9Life on 4 October 2021
  • Delivered our sustainability message to 3,241,328 viewers on Channel 9 (updated – Season 2 of the show reach 5,311,461 viewers in Auustralia and is now available on Hulu in the US, AMC+ in Europe, Disney+, Samsung TV+ and the Discovery Channel)
  • Created a top rated TV show on Channel 9Life
  • CSIRO research demonstrated a statistically significant increase in desire to have a home with home energy rating above the minimum standard for Australia – 23% for non-viewers compared to 39% for viewers of the show.
  • Average increase in brand awareness of 349% for brands featured in Renovate or Rebuild
  • Renovate or Rebuild was the winner of the Communications for Impact category for the 33rd National Banksia Sustainability Awards.
How we did it

From Challenge to Lights, Camera, Action

How we used our innovation framework to go from problem to solution

About the Project

The project set out to drive the uptake of net zero energy/carbon homes in the Australian residential sector through application of a consumer mass media campaign in collaboration with a range of industry participants.

The communications strategy was developed around the creation of flagship TV show, ‘Renovate or Rebuild’, that was designed to increase consumer awareness of the benefits of net zero energy/carbon homes and to ultimately drive consumer demand and sales of net zero energy homes in Australia as well as renovations of existing homes to achieve net zero energy/carbon performance.

Background

In The Beginning – 2014 to 2017

The development of Renovate or Rebuild dates back to 2014 and extensive industry deliberation facilitated by the Department of Planning and Environment (previously Office of Environment and Heritage) through its Collaborative Sustainable Housing Initiative (CSHI). The CSHI identified a desire amongst industry to activate this market, and to harvest the resulting commercial and economic growth opportunities.

Through this engagement industry agreed a vision of the CSHI to:

“Create mainstream demand for quality homes that are comfortable and healthier to live in, are affordable, and have a positive impact on our environment.”

This vision aimed to develop a mainstream market for homes that were differentiated by their superior environmental performance over the existing housing stock. The goal was to grow construction industry jobs and revenue, as home buyers and renovators invested more in the construction aspects of higher quality homes.

Unfortunately, experience and industry opinion was that this market did not currently exist, and that consumers were ignorant of (or do not value) the benefits of environmentally sustainable housing features.

However, a significant body of research demonstrated favourable aspirations for energy efficiency and environmental sustainability, amongst Australian home buyers and renovators. Virtually all studies indicate a positive relationship between better energy performance and increased property value.

Furthermore, research showed that there was substantial latent desire for the “co- benefits” that environmentally sustainable housing can bring such as comfort, health, community, and affordability.

Whilst the research demonstrated consumer interest in energy efficient housing the challenge of how to stimulate market demand from consumers remained unresolved.

Most people in the sustainability sector thought that consumer awareness and education was the key to driving the uptake of sustainable housing but the research told a different story – the behavioural science research showed that there is no evidence that education alone has any effect on sustainable choices and therefore we needed a different approach.

James McGregor

Founder, The Blue Tribe Company

An Idea was Born – 2018

“In 2018, new social science research insights emerged from the Low Carbon Living CRC (LCLCRC) and revealed that the current ‘top down’ education approaches aimed at changing consumer behaviours to adopt sustainable housing options (including concepts like net zero energy homes) have been largely ineffective.”

One of the key findings arising from the examination of the social research undertaken by the LCLCRC is that sustainability should be communicated in a more mainstream way and in particular there was an opportunity to learn from mainstream broadcast media with an emphasis on entertainment and story-telling that has been shown to resonate with homeowner/renovators’ aspirations and lifestyles – and reflects and shapes the ordinary cultural context for home ownership/renovations.

Based on the evidence from the social research and feedback from extensive industry engagement a proposed concept for a mass media communications project was developed. The concept was to use mass media style content to generate demand from consumers and to help housing industry partners achieve product differentiation through the integration of sustainability and use of brand driven storytelling techniques with the ultimate goal to drives sales of high performance sustainable homes.

The concept had two key objectives:

  • To stimulate desire in consumers for sustainable solutions; and
  • To create a path to market for sustainable designs by showcasing of projects by builder/s with the intent of setting key design trends that the broader market aims to mimic.

To achieve this outcome an implementation plan was developed in which the concept for Renovate or Rebuild was created with the goal of creating a broadcast quality TV show about sustainable housing supported with an integrated communications framework to drive demand for energy efficient housing in Australia.

The plan sought to develop a commercially self-sustaining model due to the long timeframes required for system level change.

The project secured funding from the CRC Low Carbon Living in November 2018 to develop a pilot a TV show pilot in order to test the key elements of the proposed business model and validate the behavioural science. The pilot episode was called “Renovate or Rebuild’ and was targeted at the existing residential building stock. This project validated that a reality television show, with a supporting behaviour change framework, can influence consumer decisions towards more sustainable housing.

In mid 2018 ASBEC and the CRC for Low Carbon Living also developed Growing the market for sustainable homes – a roadmap outlining four steps to build momentum:

  • differentiate sustainable housing in the market
  • train and reward the construction industry
  • build awareness (the mass media approach)
  • broadcast the positive business case

Growing the Market for Sustainable Homes: Industry Roadmap acted as a key catalyst to bring together key stakeholders to implement the mass media project.

In addition to the above, economic modelling undertaken by the CSIRO indicated that this demand driven approach has the potential to create a rapid uptake in sustainable housing and would yield the following benefits by 2030:

  • Half of all homes built to zero energy standard (increasing to two thirds by 2040)
  • Deliver more than half a billion dollars of extra investment in the construction industry
  • Create over 7,000 new jobs
  • Save Australians $600 million on their energy bills.

The economic modelling also suggested that the mass media communications strategy proposed for this project is able to achieve a catalytic impact at a much lower cost to government ($20 million) compared with providing subsidies under the ‘incentivised transition’ scenario ($500 million).

Economic modelling by the CSIRO suggests that the use of a mass media campaign and the demand driven approach is 25 times more effective than an incentivised transition using grants and subsidies.

Testing the Idea -2019

In early 2019 a 30 minute pilot episode was produced and tested with a series of consumer focus groups run by the CSIRO as well as utilising online analytics data. The outcome of this validation process confirmed that the target audience was strongly engaged with the show, that the show create consumer desire for more information, and that the format was able to shift consumer behavioural intent.

The validation process also provided areas requiring improvement, in particular that the show needed to provide more detail on the “sustainability features” featured in the show.
As a consequence of this validation process a full series concept was developed based on a 1 hour format.
In late 2019 Channel 9 committed to broadcast a full series of Renovate or Rebuild.

Pilot Episode

Lights, Camera, Action

Production of season 1 commenced in February 2021 and broadcast on Channel 9Life on 4 October 2021.

Season 2 is currently in production and expected to go to air in early 2024.

Renovate or Rebuild was the top rated show on Channel 9Life for the Monday broadcast reaching over 3.2million viewers for the series.

James McGregor

Founder, The Blue Tribe Company

Show Format

Renovate or Rebuild is a 60-minute lifestyle show where two teams compete to convince a family that they have the best solution to providing more space, comfort and reduced energy bills.

Team Renovate believe the family should renovate their existing home, while Team Rebuild think the family should knock down and rebuild.

In each episode you are taken on a journey through the design process whilst exploring amazing homes and products as the teams juggle the challenges of meeting the clients brief and budget whilst aiming to create an amazing design for a home that is healthy, comfortable and efficient.

The two solutions are judged by an expert panel on style, sustainability, and cost but ultimately the decision will come down to the family – will they renovate or rebuild?

The Impact of the Project

Outcomes

Research Findings

The CSIRO undertook a study to understand consumer thoughts and reactions to the first season of ‘Renovate or Rebuild’. Specifically, the study employed a series of focus groups and surveys with the following aims:  

  • To understand the impact of the TV pilot on the audience;
  • Level of brand awareness before and after the show; and
  • To understand what behavioural intentions the audience have after viewing the TV show.

The following are the key research findings:

  • Statistically significant increase in desire to have a home with home energy rating above the minimum standard for Australia – 23% for non-viewers compared to 39% for viewers of the show.
  • Average increase in brand awareness of 349% for brands featured in Renovate or Rebuild
  • The content was engaging for the target audience and viewers generally wanted more information about design considerations and energy efficiency features
  • The audience was highly engaged with 52% of YouTube viewers watching the full 30-minute pilot episode (typical retention for a 30min video on Youtube is 10%). The data also indicated that if someone watch to the end of the first segment then the show had 100% audience retention after this (this demonstrates the show was engaging and maintained people’s attention).

Viewers

%

Non-viewers Desire for Energy Efficient Home

%

Viewers Desire for Energy Efficient Home

Broader Industry Impact

Preliminary economic modelling undertaken by the CSIRO to evaluate the impact of BlueTribeCo’s proposed strategy has found that accelerating Australia’s transition to sustainable housing using a mass media communication approach would deliver more than half a billion dollars of extra investment in the construction industry by 2030 and create over 7,000 new jobs resulting in two thirds of all new homes being built to a zero energy standard by 2040. It would also save Australians $600 million on their energy bills.

The results of this modelling supported the creation of an industry road map outlined in the ASBEC report “Growing the Market for Sustainable Homes: Industry Roadmap“.

  • New Homes built to Net Zero Energy Standard by 2030 50% 50%
  • New Homes Built to Net Zero Energy Standard by 2040 67% 67%

MILLION Dollars Extra Investment in Construction Industry

New Jobs Created

MILLION Dollars Saved on Australians Energy Bills

Times more effective than an incentivised transition using grants and subsidies

Awards

Renovate or Rebuild was recognised in the worlds longest running and Australia’s most prestigious sustainability award as the national winner of the Communications for Impact Award for the 33rd National Banksia Sustainability Awards in 2022.

Considered the ‘Oscars’ of sustainability awards, the only other TV show to win a Banksia Award was the ABC’s War on Waste.

Conclusion

The following are some of the key outcomes from the project:

  • The strategy employs a systems level evidence and science-based approach to driving the mass market uptake of sustainable housing.
  • The communications framework can be used for any sustainable product or service.
  • Renovate or Rebuild delivered our sustainability message to 3,241,328 viewers in its premiere season and was the top-rated TV show on Channel 9Life.
  • The research shows that we can increase desire for home features and products in a targeted way.

Want to make your own TV show?

We have created a product specifically for Industry Associations, Not-for-profits, and Purpose Driven Businesses to help them get their message to millions of viewers by designing and creating their own TV show.

We use the same award winning communicatons framework developed for Renovate or Rebuild to get your message seen by millions.

Best of all this can all be achieved with minimal or no cash investment from you. Click the button to learn more.

Start a Project

Need help with a Project?

Deliver world changing sustainability outcomes by working with us

Schedule a Call

Schedule a free 15min online consultation where we will get a bit more information from you on your needs.  After this consultation we will send you a custom proposal with a clear plan to make real progress happen.

Accept the Proposal

Simply accept the proposal and we’ll get started on creating more impact together.

Unleash your Impact Superpowers!

We’ll work with you so you can tick that sustainability project off your list and start to measure and report on the outcomes. You might do a little happy dance, submit your project for an award and then start to tackle your next game-changing initiative.